No Clear Voices

This is a collection of sounds collected and cataloged by Beth Fileti. In type-setting, I think a lot about the concepts of readability versus legibility. Legibility refers to whether or not you can read something, regardless of how difficult it may be. If you can figure it out, something is technically legible. It is also subject to the time available to the reader. Maybe something is technically legible given enough time, but if it's on a billboard, legibility comes down to a few seconds. Legibility is a binary.

The Dataset

Waiting for the R

Collected on May 31, 2022

It sounds like a cavernous space, quieter than a typical subway station. The usual station noises were confined to other areas and the few people sharing this downstairs alcove with me stood apart, quiet with each other and ourselves. There are the muffled noises from other parts of the station, other platforms, announcements, and bustle.

Court Street Station - Waiting for the R

School Day, Remsen St

Collected on June 1, 2022

A quiet white noise, but if you turn the volume up you can hear kids playing outside. A door opens and there is the faintest rustle of someone moving within the room.

Remsen Street, in an apartment down the block from a school

Walking, Remsen St

Collected on June 1, 2022

The slight sounds of footsteps, cars passing, and conversations. There is an occasional bird in the background. Some conversations get closer or further and the recorder moves down the street, past a group of parents waiting for their kids after school.

Remsen Street, walking conversations

370 Jay St Courtyard

Collected on June 1, 2022

There is a quiet hum of activity, punctuated a few times by clearer voices or construction activity. At one moment, there is the flapping of a pigeon. There is traffic in the distance, but more chatter than that. Some children playing but they are not close to where this is recorded.

370 Jay St, courtyard

Borough Hall

Collected on June 1, 2022

The recording starts in motion, walking in front of Borough Hall and past the skateboarders. There are some clearer words and phrases here as conversations come and go in passing. The recorder is stalled at a crosswalk, and there are sounds of traffic and of waiting for a light to change. People continue talking in the background.

Borough Hall

370 Jay St, in the Rain

Collected on June 1, 2022

An angry skateboarder repeatedly slams their board and yells at the rain, before heading down into the subway.

Out front of 370 Jay St, in the rain

370 Jay St, in the Rain - 2

Collected on June 1, 2022

Standing in the outdoor lobby in front of 370 Jay St, while people rush to get to the subway and out of the rain. A couple passes and it sounds as though they are disagreeing over something, but the moment is too short to really tell.

Out front of 370 Jay St

First Day of ITP Camp

Collected on June 1, 2022

The sound of the 4th floor at 370 Jay St when several students were quietly working. There is some movement and activity as things are picked up and put down. In the far off distance there is a presentation or introduction.

The first day of ITP Camp on the 4th Floor

Vestibule, Remsen St

Collected on June 2, 2022

Standing in the vestibule of an apartment on Remsen St. There are birds from outside and a few voices behind a door. A door opens and the recording moves outside, where the birds become louder and a car horn sounds. Footsteps are heard and move past a conversation.

Vestibule and outside an apartment on Remsen St

Down the Street, DC

Collected on June 2, 2022

Sitting under a tree in DC, which is providing enough shelter to avoid getting wet. The rain starts slow in the background, until it suddenly picks up.

Down the street in DC

Kumon Waiting Room

Collected on June 4, 2022

A child is making humming noises while someone tries to maintain the quiet. The lobby of a study center, there are doors opening, footsteps, and a few words of greeting. The muffled conversations of people trying to keep a space undistracting.

Kumon Waiting Room

Amtrak, DC to NYC

Collected on June 4, 2022

On a train traveling from DC to NYC. There is a repetitive rocking noise as the train winds down the tracks. As the door between cars opens, the white noise gets louder until the door shuts again. There are a few faint conversations in the background.

Amtrak DC to NYC

Clarks, a late breakfast

Collected on June 6, 2022

An outdoor cafe area, sitting by a table chatting away but seperated enough to feel apart. A waiter gently offers their services before moving along to let you sit in the space. There are a few noises of the street and of dishes.

Late breakfast at Clarks in warm weather

By the Window, Remsen St

Collected on June 4, 2022

Some rustlings of movement with a muffled conversation from the street which floats its way in through the window of a garden-level apartment. There are a few birds chirping but it is quieter due to distance and structures in-between.

Remsen St, by the window

Harry's, Joralemon St

Collected on June 8, 2022

In a small deli named Sunny's but called Harry's by the young girl on roller blades who came in with her friend. She skated back and forth and they talk excitedly. After the recording, a woman came in to pay for the tea she bought yesterday but didn't have the money for. Two other customers came in and were greeted by name. They asked if she had been sick and the girl on roller blades shared that she still has pink eye but isn't contagious and can go to school. She asked if the man taking the money was taller than Dante.

Harry's, Girl on Roller Blades

Caldwell Diner, Sunday Breakfast

Collected on February 12, 2023

Caldwell Diner Vestibule Sunday Breakfast

33, 6:30am Express to NYC

Collected on June 14, 2022

DeCamp 33 Express to NYC

Mild morning in the park

Collected on January 4, 2023

Grover Cleveland Park, a foggy, but mild, January morning

Dance in Madison Square Park, NYC

Collected on October 20, 2022

Madison Square Park, performance

Unsure

Collected on October 20, 2022

The poorly named New Recording 22

Penn Station to Newark Broad. Tuesday

Collected on February 21, 2023

NJTransit, 7:18 train from Penn Station to Newark Broad, on a Tuesday

Early Saturday at Port Authority

Collected on June 11, 2022

Port Authority Bus Terminal, early Saturday

West Essex Diner, Thursday Dinner

Collected on March 9, 2023, 7:19pm

Please don't forget to recall the child in a metallic alien outfit and the oddly-shaped briefcase.

West Essex Diner, 7pm on a Thursday

Red Eye Cafe, a Thursday in March

Collected on March 16, 2023

Someone orders an omelette.

Red Eye Cafe, Thursday in March

Waiting for the 1 Downtown, after Tosca

Collected on March 30, 2023

1 Downtown, after Tosca

Unsure

Collected on April 19, 2023

Unknown due to poor titling, from 04/19/2023

9:11a 195x Bus from Willowbrook to NYC

Collected on April 28, 2023

195x Bus from Willowbrook to NYC

NJTransit Hall in Penn Station, Waiting for Track Announcement

Collected on April 28, 2023

Penn Station, NJTransit Hall

Exhibit at the Whitney

Collected on April 28, 2023

Exhibit at the Whitney

Lecture Hall at Montclair State University, Saturday Morning

Collected on May 06, 2023

Before taking my daughter on her first college tour. Group of parents and students collected in a lecture hall, waiting for a presentation. Later, on the tour, we walked past a student in a bathrobe, smoking weed and taking in the skyline of New York City.

Lecture Hall at Montclair State University

Little League, Wednesday Evening in May

Collected on May 10, 2023

Little League in May

143 kids in their first ever band concert

Collected on May 11, 2023

They could barely fit on the stage. It took 30min just to get them seated.

My nephew's first band concert

Great Hill in Central Park on Mother's Day

Collected on May 14, 2023

Central Park on Mother's Day

Austin bridge, waiting for bats

Collected on May 19, 2023

The bats never came. There was heat lightning in the distance.

Austin Bridge, waiting for bats

Blanton Museum of Art

Collected on May 20, 2023

Saturday Afternoon, Blanton Museum

Patio at Egan's

Collected on May 30, 2023

Patio at Egan's

Balloon Fest, Saturday Evening in Early June

Collected on June 3, 2023

NJ Balloon Fest

Unsure

Collected on June 17, 2023

Terribly sloppy record keeping

Port Authority, Friday Night in June

Collected on June 24, 2023

Port Authority

Penn Station, Wednesday Rush Hour

Collected on June 28, 2023

Penn Station, rush hour

First Exploratory Making Class

Collected on July 10, 2023

Exploratory Making @ NYU

NJTransit, Monday Morning Commute

Collected on July 10, 2023

Conductors talking. Transhit and Amtrash.

NJTransit train

UAW on Strike, Court St on a Monday

Collected on July 17, 2023

UAW on Strike, Court St on a Monday

Before Mean Girls, Friday Show in July

Collected on July 21, 2023

Youth Theater Performance

A Express Train

Collected on July 24, 2023

A woman had a purse that she designed and was asking a group of twentysomethings to test it out and give her feedback on the style.

A Express Train

WTC, Path train to the A/C on a Wednesday

Collected on August 09, 2023

WTC, mid-morning on a Summer Wednesday

Fish Cheeks, NYC, Thursday Evening

Collected on August 24, 2023

Fish Cheeks, NYC

Dough, Saturday Night in August

Collected on August 12, 2023

Dough, August Saturday

End of a Pier, Lake George

Collected on September 16, 2023

Lake George

Workers in Our Backyard

Collected on September 27, 2023

Workers in the Backyard

Art 14C, Rainy October in Jersey City

Collected on October 14, 2023

Art 14C

Grover Cleveland Park, Unseasonably Warm October

Collected on October 27, 2023

Grover Cleveland Park

This is a collection of sounds collected and cataloged by Beth Fileti. In type-setting, I think a lot about the concepts of readability versus legibility. Legibility refers to whether or not you can read something, regardless of how difficult it may be. If you can figure it out, something is technically legible. It is also subject to the time available to the reader. Maybe something is technically legible given enough time, but if it's on a billboard, legibility comes down to a few seconds. Legibility is a binary.

Readability refers to the ease with which something can be read. It is a gradient. How well has text been set determines how easy it is for a reader to accidentally fall into reading. It also refers to how easy does the process of automated reading become. For this sketch, I wanted to try and collect sounds from my life which played with a similar question of ease of understanding.

Inherent Problems with This Dataset

First, I had no rigor in the collecting process. If I was somewhere and felt like it would be a good moment to record, I would. I am sure that I missed many opportunities to collect sounds. I also tried to avoid collecting in the same spot. If I grow this collection, I feel that I might change that. Locations aren't the same on different days or at different times of the day. I tried to collect sounds in 1-minute blocks, but there were times I was interupted or accidentally hit a button on my phone. I decided to keep these shorter clips in the collection, despite not meeting the criteria I thought I had. There were samples that I collected but omitted because I felt that the voices were too clear. I wanted a collection of voices that were not inherently "readable." I also allowed one sound in which had no voices in it at all, but I felt like I wanted it to belong with the collection. Overall, the criteria that I used for this group was entirely personal to me, poorly defined, and was easily shifted depending on my mood.